Bhagavadgita Pages, Chapters 1 to 18
BG01 BG02 BG03 BG04 BG05 BG06 BG07 BG08 BG09 BG10 BG11 BG12 BG13 BG14 BG15 BG16 BG17 BG18
www.bhagavadgitausa.com
V.Krishnaraj
10/21/2008

Chapter Five: Yoga of Renunciation of Action
5.1:
Arjuna said:
O
Krishna, You praised (extolled) the yoga of renunciation of action and then the
yoga of action. Of these two, tell me for sure which is better.
Arjuna wants clarification from Krishna.
Krishna praised both karma yoga and Sannyāsa for gaining liberation
even for an accomplished jnāna yogi. Arjuna wanted to know for sure which
one is better.
5.2:
Sri Bhagavan said:
Both
renunciation of action and performance of action lead to salvation. Of the two,
karma yoga (yoga of action) is better than renunciation of action.
Karma
yoga can become part of one's daily activities more easily than renunciation of
action. A total renunciation of action is a difficult proposition. Between Karma
yoga and Jnāna yoga, Jnāna yoga is more difficult because it has an
intellectual flavor. Not that it is better or only the intelligent ones can
continue to practice it; but it is not suitable for every one. It takes study of
Vedanta and its application to the nature of the world; it takes more
discipline, control of the mind and the senses, and an integrated person to
perform Jnāna yoga. Vedic doctrine of liberation forms the basis for Jnāna
and Karma yoga, while devotion to a chosen or desired deity is the centerpiece
of Bhakti yoga.
Karma
yoga is cleansing of the mind by selfless work and has two conditions: Vairagya (nonattachment) and practice. As a motto, Karma yogi
says, “Not me, but you, service before self (my interest).”
“No pain, no gain” means pain (effort) for the yogi and gain for the
recipients of yogi’s wisdom
5.3:
It is common knowledge the enduring renouncer (nityasannyāsi)
neither detests nor desires; he is free from dualities, O Mighty-armed one; and
he finds release easily from bondage.
Sannyāsa is the fourth stage in the life of the twice born; Brahmacharya (student), Grihasthya (householder), and Vanaprathya (hermit) are the preceding stages. The fourth stage namely Sannyāsa (the renouncer) is giving up of all the duties of preceding stages and dharma that goes with them. The aim is to gain moksa or liberation. The Ksatriyas and Vaisyas can go up to stage three, that of a hermit, and the Sudra has to stop at stage two, that of a householder. A Brahmana only, by convention, can practice Sannyasa. The Grihastya stage is the most important stage of all, because it supports all other stages. In Vanaprathya the practitioner gives up artha, kāma and dharma (accumulation of wealth, raising a family and performing his duties); and his sole aim is moksa or liberation of soul.
There are six kinds of renouncers, Avadutta, being the most austere.
| Item | Kutichaka | Bahudaka | Hamsa | Paramahamsa | Turiyatita | Avadhuta |
| Tuft | Yes | Yes | Matted hair | No Tuft | unshaven | No rules |
| Sacred thread | Yes | Yes | Yes | No | No | No obligation |
| Staff | Yes | Yes | Yes | Bamboo staff | No | No obligation |
| Water vessel or Kamandalu, Pitaka (pedestal), Khanitra (shovel), Sikya (sling) | Yes | Yes | Yes | No | No | No obligation |
| Loin cloth | Yes | Yes | Yes. piece of cloth covering his mouth | Yes. single clothing | No clothes | No obligation |
| Vessel, Spade, Sikya | Yes | Yes | yes | Cupped palms are his bowl | No | No obligation |
| Forehead mark | Vertical line | three horizontal lines or vertical mark | Horizontal or vertical | No obligation | ||
| Holy ashes on body | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | No obligation |
| Food | eats well food. received from one house | eight mouthfuls gathered from different sources like a bee. choose food at random from any house. | eight mouthfuls gathered from eight different houses like a bee | A total of five mouthfuls gathered from five houses like a bee. Eat one meal only at night. | Prefers fruit; three mouthfuls from three houses. eats like a cow without use of hands. take food from all classes. fed by others. | eats when and if food is offered. He is like a python; the food comes to him and he does not ask for food |
| Asramas | 4th stage | 4th stage | 4th stage | 4th stage | Beyond 4th stage | Beyond 4th stage |
| possessions | Limited | Limited | Limited | Limited | may discard sacred books, staff, vessel, cloth etc. | None |
| language | Speaks | speaks | speaks | speaks | Mostly silent | No rules |
| Worship | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | No worship, No pilgrimage | No |
| Heaven | Bhuvarloka | Svargaloka | Tapoloka | Satyaloka | Final Beatitude | Final Beatitude |
An Avadutta will not cross, wade, or swim in a river for he only takes air baths. He will not climb a tree to pick a fruit. He waits like a python for the food to come to him; he has to be fed; If he is not fed he will not eat and goes hungry. Please go to Avadhuta for more details.
5.4:
The ignorant, but not the learned (Panditah) say that Sankhya (yoga) and
(karma) yoga are different. One who is expert in one gets the benefit of fruits
of both.
The aim of the various kinds of yogas is to destroy ego and find
one’s true identity, that is Atman; and the result is the experience,
Kaivalya,
bliss and liberation. Kaivalya is the state of absolute freedom and splendid
isolation; Purusa detaches itself from prakriti. Before one experiences
Kaivalya or Samadhi, one should make sure that one meets certain qualifications, known as Angas (which means limbs or body parts):
(1)
Yama (don’ts): sexual abstinence (celibacy), ahimsa (noninjury), no lies, no theft, no
greed.
(2)
Niyama (dos): meditation on Brahman or Isvara; silence (mauna); study of
Vedas (svādyāya), Upanishads, and moksa-promoting books; repeating of mantra OM;
Tapas (ascetic
practice); Sauca (clean body and mind) ; Santosha (contentment); Isvara
Pranidhāna (submission to God, God-Pleasing actions).
(3)
Asana*: body positions and postures.
(4)
Prānayama: breath control .
(5) Pratyahara (withdrawal): no contact
between senses and objects of senses. This should come natural to him.
(6)
Dharana: concentration and focus of mind on an object or idea .
(7) Dyana: meditation.
(8) Samādhi: Convergence, one-pointedness,
Subject and object (Yogi) unity.
Asana*: Go to file Tantra Three Tirumantiram for details on Asanas.
As
you see, this is demanding. Once somebody has gone through the angas and jnāna
yoga, he is already a renouncer. In another commentary, I will describe Bhakti
yoga, Saranāgati and Prapatti (self-surrender and resignation to God) which
the Alvars practiced.
Ascending these angas or steps is stepwise and progressive with no skips and jumps: first Yama, Niyama and Asana bring the body under control; second the breath comes under control; Pratyahara brings the senses under control; Dharana, Dyana and Savikalpa Samadhi bring the Manas (mind) to cessation (Ni-vritti) and buddhi alone shines. Further progress from Savikalpa to Nirvikalpa Samadhi takes the Yogi to a state of union of his atma with Brahman.
Most of the schools of yoga, voluntary (non-profit) and commercial organizations, teach only what sells easily: Asana, Pranayama, Dharana and Dyana. It is hard to sell and practice the foundation pieces, Yama and Niyama. Kaivalya and Samādhi without Yama and Niyama are hard to achieve.
Swami Sivananda says:
If you want Samadhi, you must know well the process of Dhyana. If you want Dhyana, you must know accurately the method of Dharana. If you want Dharana, you must know perfectly the method of Pratyahara. If you want Pratyahara, you must know Pranayama. If you want Pranayama you must know Asana well. Before going to the practice of Asana, you should have Yama and Niyama. There is no use of jumping into Dhyana without having the various preliminary practices. (page 154, Kundalini Yoga)
This is what Woodroffe says:
The statement of such obvious truths would hardly be necessary were it not that there are still some who see in all Yoga mere " Shamanism, feats of breathing, acrobatic posturing," and so forth. On the contrary, no country since the Middle Ages and until our own has laid greater stress on the necessity of the association of morality and religion with all forms of human activity, than India has done.
The practice of Yama and Niyama leads to renunciation of, and detachment from, the things of this world and of the next, arising from the knowledge of the permanent and impermanent, and intense desire for and incessant striving after emancipation, which characterizes him who is Mumuksu, or longs for Liberation. --The Serpent Power, page 191-192, para 1.
5.5:
That which Sankhya (yoga) helps achieve are obtainable by (karma) yoga
also. The one, who sees Sankhya yoga and karma yoga as one, sees (the truth).
5.6:
But renunciation without karma yoga, O Mighty armed one, causes distress.
One engaged in karma yoga is a
munih or sage and attains to Brahman without any
delay.
Attaining to Brahman with karma yoga is easier than with Jnāna yoga. Reaching Brahman is different from merging with Brahman. In Sankaracharya’s Advaita theory the jiva becomes one with Brahman, once ignorance lifts, and knowledge of Brahman is not far off. In Ramanujacharya's theory, atomic souls (Jiva) are distinct and separate entities, although the original source was Brahman; once it becomes an atomic entity (anu), it will not merge with God or Brahman, on liberation; but they remain as separate entities in closeness to Brahman. In Vaikuntha or Heaven, it lives a life in close friendship with Vishnu, on gaining moksa or liberation after death. Ramanuja does not believe in jivan mukti, that is liberation before death, while Videhamukta is moksa or liberation of the life monad or anu after death.
Tantrics of Kularnava Tantra believe in merging with Brahman, the Mother Goddess (here called Brahmamayi). The individual soul merges into the Mother as a river merges into the sea, losing its identity. It is called Brahmakaivalya or Nirvana. The Great Mother (Brahman/Brahmamayi) who is Consciousness without attributes, body, and parts, beyond the grasp of mind and speech, assumes forms for the sake of Sadhakas. Tantrics believe that the Brahmamayi assumes the form of Vishnu, Siva, and Brahma under names Brahmamayi, Vishnumayi, Sivamayi or Rudramayi. She is the creator, maintainer and destroyer.
Vaikuntha
is a vast region in the sky, supreme and effulgent. It is 18 crores Yojanas (14
billion miles) above the earth. All other regions, except Goloka, are below
Vaikuntha. Honey flows freely in the land of Vaikuntha. Wish-yielding trees
burst forth continuously with all-season extravaganza, all at the same time. The
residents enjoy bounty of nature including singing birds, amenities like golden
chariots and company with women with extraordinary beauty and winning smiles, not
appealing to earthbound passions.
The
word Muni is a derivation from Maunam: maunam
is silence and the practitioner is a muni.
The
Muni, the Gods, and the Wind in
Vedas
Muni,
the silent one, with his long hair flying in the wind and the saffron cloth
billowing, follows the wind and goes where gods have gone before. His munihood
is his calling card and passport to regions, where mortal men can never take
their bodies. Every time a god needs an assistant, there you see a muni in
attendance. There he is, the same
moment the god makes a wish. Such is the glory of a muni. He flies faster than
the wind (and thought), leaving us poor embodied souls breathless and sitting still. Such is his speed and
agility. When could I drop my
sloth, and slumber? Please
tell me how and when? Could I ever
be a muni? Is it in my cards? Could
I go where muni goes, please tell me? Vayu
(the wind god) is the best friend of a muni. Vayu’s steed stands waiting to
take the muni to the oceans east and west. The steed knows the sylvan beasts,
Gandharvas and Apsaras, but unafraid, gallops along, with muni at the reins. The
wind caresses his locks and his flowing beard. What tenderness! What sweetness! What
friendship! Vayu, riding
along, churns and bends to aid muni's passage. He is the muni who drinketh water
from a cup with Rudra. Note: Vishnu created Vayu, Brahma and Rudra.
Gandharvas
and Apsaras are celestial males and females respectively, engaged in fun and
frolic, dance and music; they are the purveyors of soma juice for the gods. Soma
juice, whose identity as a drink has a shroud of mystery. There are several
conflicting reports on the identity of the plant’s juice; it caused
inebriation and hallucinations. It might be a mushroom juice from Amanita
muscaria; according to scriptures, the priests (and the gods) imbibed the soma
juice before initiating sacrifices.
5.7:
A karma yogi, who is a pure soul and a conqueror of his self and his
senses, and who identifies his self with the selves of all beings, although
engaged in work, shows no change or stain.
Karma
yoga, pure by itself, does not take on any taint, if the actions are pure and
virtuous; if the senses are under control; if one performs god-loving acts and
identifies his self with the self in others. Qualities (gunas) and modifications
of Prakrti make the difference between gods and men; but the difference never
affects the self, which is the same and equal in all. Karma yogi uses his
body in the service of man and god: use of the body in karma yoga is
forgivable and his work does not taint his soul because karma yogi works in
uplifting the self of each person, he serves. The doer of this karma is the self
itself and the beneficiary is one's own self or other selves; hence, actions are
not binding, do not cause any karmic inflows into the subtle body and carry no
taint. Karma yoga is easier than Jnāna
yoga and offers benefits sooner.
A
true karma yogi saves others before he saves himself.
Ramanuja said that he would rather go to hell with all the sins of the
world and thus save the world with his mantra than to use it for himself. That
mantra is "Om Namo Narayana." Alvars considered serving the devotees of Narāyana
as serving Lord Narāyana Himself.
Isa Upanishad (Verse 6) says that he, who sees his
self in all beings and the selves of all beings in his own self, entertains no
doubt (about his conviction): Brahman is One and his manifestations are many.
5.8:
He is steady in yoga, knows the truth, and thinks without doubt that he
does not do anything, while seeing, hearing, touching, smelling, eating, moving,
sleeping, breathing, (Continued
in next verse)
5.9:
speaking, discharging (evacuation), grasping, opening, or closing his
eyes. He knows and holds (the view) the senses act in the realm of sense
objects.
All
as described earlier, these are the products of prakrti: five sensory organs, five motor organs,
manas, and prānas. Tanmatras
(merely that) by their nature act in the realm of senses and their matching
sense organs; some of them are under voluntary control and some are not. The
self itself wallows in the senses but its higher nature is stainless. It is like
pebble in a river; it is wet from water but is not soaking wet with water.
It is like diamond in dirt, but diamond is not dirt.
5.10:
He, who dedicates his works to Brahman without attachment to work, is
never subject to sin as a lotus leaf (does not get wet) by water.
Ramakrishna Paramahamsa says the following in reference to this verse: Sayings of Ramakrishna Page 88, Saying 268: What is the state of man who is in the world but is free from attachments? He is like the lotus leaf in the water, or like a mud-fish in the marsh. Neither of these is polluted by the element in which it lives. The water wets not the leaf, nor does the mud stain the glossy coat of the fish.
Once
the work is a dedication to the highest Self, action is not binding, and
proceeds from Atman itself. In this
context, Brahman is prakrti, the progenitor of all senses, sense organs and
actions. By his actions, the yogi is essentially acting in the realm of prakrti;
but once the yogi dedicates his actions to and identifies himself with Atman,
sin or karma does not contaminate his actions. Ramana Says, “Work is no work,
karma is akarma, when there is no sense of doership.”
The (images of) fire or flood in the cinema (celluloid) does not affect
the white screen (or the celluloid itself) on which the images appear (are
projected). There is so much of talk about work and attachment (but not about
dedication) to work. Thought, speech and deed generate karma with three results:
neutral, positive and negative. (More on the results later) This karma is the
cause of rebirth. The thrust of this message is on the means and methods to
avoid rebirth or transmigration of the soul, and reach Brahman or gain eternal
bliss by dedicating the work to the Lord. Simply put, dedicate the work to the
Lord and thus neutralize karma caused by actions.
5.11:
The yogis perform actions with body, mind, intelligence, and senses
without attachment for purifying the self.
5.12:
A yogin, giving up the fruits of his actions, wins everlasting peace. The
man ignorant of yoga, attached to desires of the fruits of his actions, is
always in bondage.
5.13:
The embodied soul, while controlling all his activities, renouncing them
in his mind, and remaining in happiness in the city of nine gates, is neither
working nor causes work (to be done).
Depicting
the soul as a person or body.
The
nine gates of the embodied soul are two ears, two eyes, two nostrils, mouth,
reproductive and evacuative organs. The individual soul by
itself is pristine in its free state and has no karmic loads. But once the soul
wraps itself with the body and other sheaths, it takes on a load of karma, its
fruits and consequences. Once there is no more karmic inflow, by controlling all
activities, that embodied soul is action-free and is ready for moksa.
5.14:
The Lord (the Self) does create neither the doership, nor the activities
of people, nor the connection between the activities and their fruits. But it is
the way of material nature.
The
Self is neither the doer, nor the act, nor the fruit, nor the connector between
the act and the fruit. These come naturally, according to the vāsanās
that cling to the subtle body. The law of karma is inexorable and even Lord
Krishna had to die (from an arrow shot) at the hands of a hunter, for karma is the supreme law;
demands resolution on this earth before death, if liberation is the goal; or has
to be erased by the grace of God. Karma explains the disparity and differences
among family members, communities, societies, boroughs, counties, states, countries, races, and all
unexplained and explained events, such as wars, accidents, deaths, massacres,
famines, prosperity and poverty among nations. Meritorious karma results in
meritorious fruits and unmeritorious karma results in unpleasant results; if one
keeps on doing good acts, he will take birth repeatedly enjoying the good
fruits. But the best state is null karma. Pure Freedom, according to Ramanamaha Rishi, is getting rid off all vāsanās, good and bad, which
ensures moksa or liberation.
The
Lord does not create doership, activities, connection, and their fruits. His own incarnation follows that pattern. The story behind
his incarnation illustrates this point. Krishna takes his incarnations to
destroy adharma and establish dharma. He himself could not escape the long arm
of karma. Vishnu’s incarnations were due to that karma.
Once the Asuras took
shelter in hermitage of Bhrgu Muni. Vishnu, Indra and other lesser gods seized
the hermitage and Bhrgu’s wife pleaded with gods and asked them to leave her
hermitage forthwith. She threatened to burn them down with the fire of her Tapas.
At the suggestion of Indra, Vishnu killed Bhrgu’s wife. (Bhrgu once kicked
Vishnu on his chest. The story on that incident is in the supplement section
titled “The Cagey Sages.”) Bhrgu Muni cast a curse on Vishnu saying that he
would be born a human being seven times. Bhrgu, being a muni and sage, brought
his wife back to life immediately for them to witness his power.
5.15:
The all-pervading Brahman or Supreme accepts neither the sin nor the
merit of anyone. Ignorance envelops wisdom, deluding the living creatures.
Brahman = Expansion, growth, all-pervasion.
“Everyone's sins and merits are his own.” It is unlike Christianity, in which Jesus Christ assumes the sins. Here Vibhu refers to Brahman, Narāyana, or Krishna pervading the whole universe. It is not the individual soul as explained by Ramanuja. The Sankara's Brahman is all-pervasive and there is no difference between Jiva and Brahman: They are the same. The world is a product of māyā and Avidya. Once ignorance and māyā attenuate and disappear, realization of Brahman becomes reality and Sankara's Jivas merge with Brahman on liberation. Ramana Maharishi advises his devotees to assume responsibility for their deeds and says, “If you concede that all your deeds are Siva's deeds, your being is not different from Siva's. If it is different and you claim freedom, then your deeds are yours, NOT Siva's at all."
Now the exception according Siddhantist. The deeds of enlightened souls (deeds of Ramana Maha Rishi) do not engender Karma. Siva degerms the seeds of karma-producing deeds of the enlightened souls, buries them in Maya (material cause of the universe and beings according to Saiva Siddhantist) and consigns them to rot and decay.
KAma (lust), Krodha (anger), Lobha (greed), Moha (delusion), Mada (pride), and MAtsarya (envy) are the commonly known six sins.
Wisdom,
ignorance, and delusion
According to Vallabha's philosophy of Suddhadvaita or Pure Monism, Krishna is God or Brahman or the Supreme. Vallabha's world is NOT an illusion as Sankara’s universe. The individual soul is part of Brahman; it is like a spark in the fire; it and Brahman are identical. Jiva pervades the whole being as the sandalwood aroma pervades the room. Jiva is Brahman with a difference: It is atomic in size and does not enjoy Brahman’s consciousness and bliss – which remain in a potential state- unless it gains liberation. Jiva is enveloped by Avidyam (ignorance of not appreciating that Brahman and Jiva have organic relationship with one another.) As dirt covers the diamond, I-ness, ahankāra, and the products of Prakrti cover and burden the jiva (individual soul, monad). This embodiment of Jiva by the body and samsāra (transmigratory existence or life on earth) are illusions created by I-ness or ego. Jiva forgets its origin and the support it gets from Brahman. This I-ness sets Jiva up for a conflict with other jivas and the world around it. This web of false relations with other jivas and the world around it is māyā: Soul’s body, its relationship with other jivas, and samsāra are all māyā or illusion. Achintya Bhedabheda: (Incomprehensible difference - non-difference) According to this, the individual souls are like sparks bursting out of the fire. Yes, the Jivas are non-different from Bhagavan because they are made of the same constitution. Yes, the Jivas are different from Bhagavan because Isvara (Bhagavan) is the Lord, Master and Controller of Maya Sakti and the Jivas come under the control of Isvara and His Maya.
5.16:
For those, in whom knowledge of the Self destroys ignorance, that
knowledge lights up or illumines the Supreme like the sun.
The self itself is pristine, but ignorance and inflow of karma taint it. Knowledge of the self in a person contracts with karma in samsāra, and expands with moksa or liberation. Atman has two kinds of knowledge: to paraphrase Ramanuja, one is knowledge of self, or self-awareness; and the other is external awareness (awareness of objects other than itself).
The external awareness of self
contracts with ignorance and expands with knowledge. It is like saying that you
know your "self," but are ignorant of matters other than your
"self." When that
knowledge dawns, it is like the rising sun. According to Jains, the three jewels
(Ratna Triya) are Right Belief, Right Knowledge, and Right Conduct.
There are others who interpret it differently. Ignorance is defined as not knowing the difference between the body and the soul (self): Body-soul identification is ignorance. In reality they are two entities. The ego, the veiling wall of darkness, asserts mine-ness of the body and the world and conceals the self, that is the sun. The self is stable and immutable in its structure, functions and stance, while the ego's targets, aspirations, and desires change with time and age. Self's stability against changing desires is the nature of reality; destruction of ego and embracing of the stable self amount to destruction of ignorance and acquisition of knowledge. The self is like the sun and the ego of ignorance is like darkness, dissipation of which along with acquisition of knowledge of the self reveals the sun and reality.
Gandhi says (paraphrase) that the self shines in the spiritual heart; the darkness of ignorance envelopes the light that is knowledge. When the darkness of ignorance is destroyed, the light of God is revealed. Knowledge is to be obedient to God and act according to his prompts.
There are four elements in this verse: the knowledge or the wisdom of the self, ignorance, the sun, and the Supreme. Self's inherent quality is light and wisdom, while ignorance is ego and not knowing the duality of self (soul) and body. Once the ignorance is destroyed, the innate wisdom of the self reveals the Supreme, that is Parmataman, as the sun illumines its universe.
5.17:
They, whose intelligence, mind, and faith are steady in Him and who have
taken refuge in the supreme, attain that (Supreme abode) from where there is no
return, having cleaned their sin by knowledge.
5.18:
A punditah (sage) regards (sees) with an equal eye a humble Brahmin, a
cow, an elephant, a dog, and even a dog-eater.

The Hindu sacred texts
glorify a humble Brahmin because he lives for god, man and other beings. Since
he is a preceptor, a man of god, and god’s representative on earth, even his
shadow is sacred and therefore, one should not step on his shadow (Garuda Purana
1.96.54). Brahmins, snakes,
Ksatriyas, and Atman (Brahman) should never be insulted (GP 1.96.55). Daily
study of Vedas is mandatory for a Brahmin who should never desire for wealth. He
can take charity from a king, a pupil or his clan member to satisfy his hunger
(GP 1.96.35).
GP
(1.213.3) states the duties of a Brahmin are explained in Sruti and Smrti, which
are his two eyes. The guiding principles of a Brahmin come from Sruti, Smrti and
the virtuous acts of others. Truth, charity, sympathy, renunciation, knowledge,
sacrifice, worship and self-control are the eight qualities of the virtuous.
Krishna Paramatma expresses a similar sentiment in The Uddhava Gita, Dialogue Five, Verse 7. In this instance, Krishna includes things and people in the list. Since things have Self, wanton destruction of things is not respecting the Self.
7 All people and things must become equal
In the eyes of such a devotee
Be they spouse, children, home or wealth, Friends or relatives.
The devotee must seek only the Self in all.
--Translation by Swami Sarasvati.
Once Ramakrishna Paramahamsa (year 1855) was faced with a broken idol of Krishna. The priest carrying the idol of Krishna dropped it and the idol's right foot was broken in several places at the base of the toes. The learned pundits told Ramakrishna Parmahamsa that a broken idol cannot be worshipped and therefore should be immersed (disposed of) in the Ganges River. The proprietress of the temple Rani Rasmani was very sad. RKPH came up with a solution. He told Rani that she would not throw away her son-in-law with a broken leg but take him to a doctor to mend the fracture. RKPH repaired and reattached the toes of the idol and installed it for worship against the established rules of temple worship. Here we see an instance of what Krishna himself said thousands of years ago that "things" and people have Self. He had to break his toes to illustrate his point. Krishna made the priest drop the idol, break his toes and let RKPH repair them and restore the sanctity of the idol, thus showing the equality of people and things, a concept alien to many people.
All beings are dear not for the sake of being, but for the sake of Self
(Br. UP 2.4.5). Brahman is all-pervasive both in the insentient and the
sentient, and from ameba to man. In man, the sentience expresses the most and in the
ameba, it expresses the least. The soul is the same but the embodiment is
different and the pundit sees and feels that all living beings are equal.
To put
it succinctly, there is a metaphysical unity in empirical diversity. This is one
of the underlying precepts for ahimsa, noninjury. The souls in the animals have
to climb the evolutionary ladder, before these souls can attain to Brahman. The
soul has fallen on hard times and the animal soul could have been a human soul
in the previous birth; this step down is because of karma; the animal soul has
to take on a human body before it can gain moksa. The quality and the nature of
Atman in the animals and human beings are the same, but prakrti makes the
difference. The pristine nature and intrinsic knowledge of Atman in the animal
is no different from that of the human. Mahat or buddhi consists of three
entities, namely subconsciousness, consciousness, and superconsciousness. In
animals, the subconsciousness or mere consciousness is the instinctive mind,
which by its nature lacks reason and intuition. Intuition is defined as present
knowledge in continuum from previous existence. By the instinctive mind, a bird
builds a nest, and an animal avoids a poisonous plant; fish or animal, when faced
with a new set of circumstances alien to its instinct, is dead in the water, or
out of its element and resources. The Self or Atman is All-Knower and
All-Knowledge; all our knowledge comes from the Atman or Soul. The receptiveness
of the animal's brain is low and that of the human brain is high. The animal's
inadequate brain can manifest only instinct drawn from the subconscious self,
while the human brain, more developed and more receptive, displays not only
instincts, but also reason, intellect, and intuition. In yogis more (all-knowing) eternal
knowledge percolates through. Another way of putting it is how much a person
reflects the all-knowing Atman in him. The more a person reflects, the more of a
yogi he becomes. To sum up, animals have instinct and subconsciousness (mere
consciousness); man has instinct, reason, intellect, intuition, and self-consciousness.
Instinct, reason, intellect, intuition, self-consciousness, and superconsciousness are
present in Yogis. Logic (reason), intelligence, and science work well within the
scope of the phenomenal world but do not offer any spiritual inspiration or
revelation. What is important for an individual self is not being but becoming.
Death is not the end of the journey but only the next step for the individual
soul to reach its goal of becoming which is superconsciousness.
The
more learned one is, the humbler he becomes. The riper the fruits are, the
greater and lower the branches bend: Knowledge is humility. The soul of a
dog-eater or a Brahmin is of the same source and therefore can receive SatChitAnanada, Being-Awareness-Bliss. There are no double standards here.
A
dog-eater, in this verse, means that he is a person of mixed caste, most likely a
Chandala, born of a Brahmin mother and Sudra father.
Mixed
castes according to Garuda Purana 1.96-1-73, as narrated by Yajnavalkya.
|
Father |
Mother |
The
offspring |
|
Brahmin |
Ksatriya |
Muurdhaabhisikta |
|
Brahmin |
Vaisya |
Ambastha |
|
Brahmin |
Sudra |
Nisaada,
Parvata |
|
Ksatriya |
Vaisya |
Maahisya |
|
Ksatriya |
Sudra |
Mleccha |
|
Vaisya |
Sudra |
Karana |
|
Ksatriya |
Brahmin |
Suta
(Sūta) |
|
Vaisya |
Brahmin |
Vaidehaka |
|
Sudra |
Brahmin |
Chandaala
(Lowliest of all) |
|
Vaisya |
Ksatriya |
Maagadha |
|
Sudra |
Ksatriya |
Ksattr |
|
Sudra |
Vaisya |
Ayogava |
|
Maahisya |
Karanii |
Rathakaara |
ThAkura lists twelve qualities of a Brahmana: truthfulness, control of the senses, austerity, freedom from malice, modesty, tolerance, freedom from envy, sacrifice, charity, fortitude, studying the Vedas, and accepting vows. Page 51- Jaiva Dharma.
5.19:
Even here, they, whose mind, standing firm in equality, conquer the
created (phenomenal world). Brahman is flawless and equal in all and so are the
persons who stand firm in Brahman.
Prakrti
covers and contaminates the individual soul. Brahman is free from such
contamination and thus is the same in everybody. Knowing that Prakrti-free
selves are equal, they stand firm in Brahman.
5.20:
He neither rejoices for getting that which is pleasant nor laments at
getting that which is unpleasant. Since he is steady in his intelligence without
confusion, the knower of Brahman or God stands firm in God.
Brahmani
Sthitah: Stands firm in Brahman, established in Brahman.
The sweet and sour experiences, compared with those of the birds on the tree, are those of the body and not of the self, and therefore, the stainless self, thus knowing, abides in Brahman. Logic, reason and human intelligence, (intuitive intelligence is a separate entity) do not measure up to understand and know Brahman and the study of scriptures is only a preliminary step in that process. Brahman is the thread that runs through all living entities as in a garland, binds all living entities high and low, and holds and moves the puppets of the world of beings and nature.
Knower of Brahman is one who possesses Brahman knowledge, the knowledge of the Self. Panchadasi (4.55-69) quotes Suresvara, saying that he who pretends to be a knower of Brahman without any moral restraint is like a dog with unclean eating habits. The knower of Truth does not wallow in impurities like a pig in a sty. He who rises above the impurities and desires of the mind is worthy of worship as if he is god. A man who wades in his mind in the river of passions, gets wet with those passions which lead him to attachment, longing, frustration and anger. These can be avoided by meditation on formless Brahman. Once the mind erases the world of matter from its memory, the mind ceases to dwell on the objects and becomes blank like a clean slate; he acts like a dumb and mute person. He is on the doorway opening into the world of Nirvana. If the mind wanders into objects of desire, it is easy for him to bring it back to tranquil state by meditation. He who knows no distraction is a knower of Brahman; he is Brahman Itself. He, who is not concerned whether he is in union with Brahman or not, is Brahman Itself.
5.21:
He, whose soul (mind) has shed all attachments to external contacts
(sense objects), enjoys ease in the self. He, with his “self” absorbed in
Brahma yoga, enjoys undying (imperishable) happiness or bliss.
5.22:
Certainly, the accompanying pleasures from contacts with sense objects
are seats of sorrow. They have a beginning and an end, O Kaunteya, and the wise
do not take any pleasure in them.
Kaunteya: Son of Kunti, or Arjuna. The fleeting pleasures resulting from the contact of the senses with the sense objects are a source of pain. Knowing that they are Atman, they do not indulge themselves in such pursuits and abide in Brahman. The story of two birds explains this. The first bird is the witness, not eating any fruits. The companion bird eats sweet and sour fruits, alternating between pleasure and pain, until it finds wisdom from its own self and abides in the Self.
5.23:
He, who can endure the flood of desire and anger, before he gives up his
body, is a yogin and a happy man.
Vega:
rush, force, flood
Here
and now, there is a promise of wisdom and happiness.
Only
if one longs for the experience of the self, he gives up desire and anger. There
is no implication here that the person controlling himself and experiencing the self
will get jivan-mukti, liberation when he is alive. This yogin, having fried his
karmic seeds, remains in Kaivalya and Samādhi.
5.24:
He, who finds happiness, pleasure, and the inner light within his self,
is a yogin and attains to Brahman and the bliss of Brahman or beatitude of
Brahman.
5.25:
The sage, who restrains his mind, whose sins come to naught (are destroyed),
whose doubts and dualities undergo dissolution (are dissolved), and who shows
devotion (is devoted) to the welfare of all beings, attains to Bliss of Brahman.
The
sage restrains his mind, he destroys his sins, he clears his doubts and
transcends his dualities, he devotes his life to the welfare of all living
creatures, and he attains to the bliss of Brahman and Brahman Himself.
5.26:
The beatitude of Brahman is imminent in the ascetic, who removed his desire and
anger, whose mind exercises restraint, and who has knowledge of the self.
Matted hair, deerskin, and pious pretension do not make an
ascetic. An
ascetic in name and epicure in practice, though he professes to know Brahman, is
far away from Brahman. Appearance does not make an ascetic, though he wanders
naked and shameless; a donkey does the same.
Jackals, rodents and deer live in the forest, eat grass, and drink water:
are they ascetics? The frogs and fish take birth, eat and die in Ganga. Are they
ascetics? –Garuda Purana, II.49.64-67-68.
This passage has reference to
Avadutas, who renounce the world and live on
what is offered to them or on leaves, roots and fallen fruits.
Avadhûta = one who has shaken off himself worldly feeling and obligation.
Here is what Sankara says in Bajagovindam about a false ascetic.
Verse 14. (There goes) one with matted hair; (here comes) one with shaven head; (there sits) yet another with plucked hair and saffron cloth; the fools sport various disguises. They all claim to "see;" (What they "see" no one knows and neither he knows what he "sees.") In reality he does not "see." All this Vesha (disguise) is to fill the belly.
5.27:
Abandoning all sense objects, fixing the gaze
between the eyebrows, and
keeping the movement of air up and down (Prāna, Apāna) the nostrils in
equilibrium within the nostrils, (continued)
Between the eyebrows: antare bhruvoh or Bhru madhya. √ Bhram = Brow. As you see here Brow is derived from Sanskrit word Bhram.
5.28:
The sage, who has controlled his senses, mind, and intellect; who has his
highest aim moksa or liberation; and who freed himself from desire, fear, and
anger, is forever free (liberated).
Prāna and Apāna breaths: See comment on
verse 9 chapter 10 for details.
5.29:
Knowing me thus as the enjoyer of all sacrifices and austerities (Yajana-tapasam)
and the supreme Lord of this whole world or universe, the Friend of all living
beings, one attains peace.
Any sacrifice, made to any gods goes to Lord Krishna Himself, since He is the Supreme Lord of all souls, including those of gods. He is the universe and the enjoyer of all Sacrifices. He is the friend of all the devotees, easy of access, loving as a parent, kind, and compassionate with infinite grace, though inscrutable. He is the knowledge, the Knower, and Doer but the Unknowable too.
Paramahamsa Babaji says the following on Krishna. Parabrahma Krishnachandra is the one and only Infinite Substance (brhad vastu) and the jivas are his innumerable atomic particles. Like sparks emanating from an undivided fire, the jivas emanate from Krishna, who is the embodiment of innumerable consciousness. The jiva has the full function of consciousness, with which he should seek Krishna.
End of Chapter Five: Yoga of Renunciation of Action